SUBPLOT The story under the story. Breakdowns, theories, reactions, opinions, reviews and lore from the people who actually watch it.
Sun, 22 November 2026 36 creators writing here Become a SubPlotter →
← Back to the front page
ReactionDC

Joker: Folie à Deux review: why did the sequel fail?

A year after its release, the musical sequel to Todd Phillips' Joker undoes the first film, wastes its songs and traps Arthur Fleck in a story he barely drives.

The Gold Man (AI-assisted)20 November 2026Editor: Digital Fox Talent Editorial TeamOn YouTube since 2014 · more than 170,000 subscribers 2,560 words · 12 min read
Joker: Folie à Deux review: why did the sequel fail?

Joker: Folie à Deux is a movie people hate, and I'm one of them. The 2024 sequel, starring Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga, arrived after the enormous success of the first film. Fans were skeptical of it from the start, and once they saw it, they felt every concern they had was vindicated.

Some fans went out of their way to say director Todd Phillips made this movie as an insult aimed at anyone who liked the original. So why do people hate it so much, and what happened behind the scenes that led to this final product? I'll start with the big picture, then move to the specific reasons the movie doesn't work.

Why Joker (2019) was a billion dollar success

Joker came out in 2019 and was an unquestionable success. Its budget was only around $55 million, and it went on to gross $1.078 billion. It captured audiences in a way superhero movies and blockbusters typically don't. Yes, it was based on a popular comic book character, arguably the most popular comic book villain, but the movie was so much more than that.

It was uncomfortable. It was violent. It was shockingly real. It depicted mental illness and class conflict in a way we had never seen in a comic book movie. Joaquin Phoenix won the Oscar for best actor, which had never happened for a comic book movie before. The film also sparked conversation, both from comic book fans and from media stories, which I'd call fabricated, claiming the movie would lead to mass shootings and uprisings. Todd Phillips didn't just create a movie. He started a conversation.

When a movie makes that kind of money on that kind of budget, a sequel is going to be made. Every movie in history that has made a billion dollars is part of an IP in some way, besides Titanic. But Joker was a standalone story, and I think fans loved it for that. Before release, Phillips said he could be interested in a sequel if the film was successful, but he was clear: "the movie is not set up to have a sequel. We always pitched it as one movie and that's it."

How Joaquin Phoenix and Todd Phillips landed on a musical sequel

So what changed? Both Phoenix and Phillips had always been somewhat interested. Phoenix has said he wasn't ready to leave Arthur Fleck behind when making the first movie. He even described a dream of his character performing on stage, telling jokes and singing, which gave him the idea of a possible musical sequel. Some reports suggested Phoenix and Phillips discussed telling the sequel as a Broadway show.

So even before the sequel was greenlit, the musical angle had captured them as far back as 2019. It wasn't until June 2022 that the movie was officially announced. Phoenix and Phillips would return, the film would be titled Joker: Folie à Deux, and Lady Gaga would play Harley Quinn. Apparently, Phoenix loved the idea of a female Joker appearing in the sequel, so including Harley Quinn seemed like a no brainer.

Todd Phillips kept Joker: Folie à Deux away from DC

A lot of this sounds like corporate sequel nonsense, and that might be fair, but there's more to it, and it gives some insight into what kind of filmmaker Phillips is. When the movie was greenlit in 2022, DC was a mess and in the middle of a major studio transition. James Gunn had become the new head of DC with plans to start a new cinematic universe. Joker 2 would not be part of that and was going to be labeled an Elseworlds story.

During postproduction, Gunn gave some notes on the movie, but he was mostly hands off. Phillips, the man who directed the first movie, rejected those ideas. Supposedly, he wanted nothing to do with DC while making the film. He had been given all the creative control in the world, and since he got the job before Gunn arrived, there wasn't much Gunn could do. As a result, no DC executives were involved in making the film. There isn't a single DC logo at the start of the movie. That's how isolated Phillips wanted to be from a DC property, despite Joker being a DC property.

I think this mentality says a lot about his approach. Some say the film was a middle finger to anyone who liked the first movie. Others say it was an honest sequel that people just don't get. Either way, if you watch it with the idea that Phillips wanted to be a contrarian to everything DC and comic book films represent, a lot starts to make sense. When they discussed making it a musical, he loved the idea because of how dangerous and risky it was. I think he saw the direction most fans wanted and thought it would be special to go the complete opposite way.

Why I think Arthur not being the Joker undoes the first film

Phillips was keenly aware of the source material. He teased Arthur heading down the path of the Joker in the trailers, then took the story somewhere else. One of his most famous comments about these films was that there was a reason they're called Joker and not The Joker. By the end of Joker 2, we know why: Arthur isn't the Joker. I think that's one of the most disingenuous quotes I've ever seen from a comic book director. He's admitting to leading the audience to expect one thing while planning to give them something else, using the popularity of the Joker to tell a story that is nothing like any Joker story.

Back when the first movie came out, a popular theory was that Arthur would inspire the real Joker. I think that idea works better as a theory than as official canon. And I'm not against bending source material. There's a time and place for a twist, and the first Joker is exactly that, since Arthur doesn't really reflect any of the major versions of the character.

The first movie uses a technique common in franchise storytelling now: start a familiar character in a radically different state so that, by the end, they become the version fans know. Man of Steel does this, with Zack Snyder starting with a Clark Kent who doesn't resemble Superman, who was meant to become him by the end of the now unfinished Snyderverse. The Rings of Power does it with Galadriel. Joker worked where these didn't because it only took one movie for Arthur to resemble the Joker, while the others would need five movies or five seasons. But the point of that twist is that you don't radically change the character after their arc is complete.

Joker 2 does the exact opposite. It begins with what feels like a more familiar version of the character and ends with him renouncing the title and dying at the hands of the real version. That's unsatisfying, and it undoes the first movie. Imagine if Batman Begins ended with Gordon handing Batman the Joker card, and then The Dark Knight killed the Joker in the bank scene and made Harley Quinn the real villain. That's not good storytelling, no matter how surprising it is. Storytelling is about setups and payoffs, and this ending wasn't set up properly, so the payoff was weak and disappointing.

Why I think Todd Phillips owed fans a satisfying sequel

If you'd never heard of DC Comics, Joker 2 might be enjoyable to you. But the first movie only made a billion dollars because the Joker is a popular comic book character. If it had been called Clownface, I don't think it would have made that kind of money. Phoenix, Phillips and Lady Gaga reportedly made a combined $52 million for Joker 2, and I don't think they'd be paid that much if the title character weren't the most popular comic book villain of all time.

So if you're getting paid tens of millions of dollars, I think you owe it to the property to make a movie that is at the bare minimum satisfying to the source material. It doesn't have to honor it completely, just be mildly satisfying. Phillips told a story that was fundamentally unsatisfying to DC fans, and he told it ineffectively. Taking a beloved character and angering your audience because you think it's cool or edgy needs to be called out.

Why the musical numbers in Joker: Folie à Deux don't work

Now let's pretend Phillips wanted to make the most honorable Joker sequel possible. It still doesn't work. Saying the musical side failed isn't original commentary, but I find it strange that it was one of the weakest parts of the film when it seems to be the part Phillips and Phoenix were most excited about. There are no reports of Phillips planning to undermine the character back in 2019, but there were reports of a musical. The best evidence is that they cast Lady Gaga, who has some acting credits but is, I think, mostly known for her music.

I'm no expert on musicals. I'd go as far as calling myself musically challenged. But I know music is supposed to sound good, which is why they cast one of the most popular singers in the world opposite Phoenix. Unlike Lady Gaga, Phoenix isn't a good singer, at least not in this movie. Arthur's voice isn't appealing to hear, especially singing. Songwriters may praise the lyrics, but if it doesn't sound good, it won't work. Taylor Swift's The Life of a Showgirl wouldn't be as successful if I sang every song instead of her.

The scenes themselves don't work either. Musicals let characters tell the audience how they feel in a way that isn't cringey, and those numbers should matter to the characters' development. My favorite movie of summer 2025 was probably KPop Demon Hunters, and it would be terrible without its songs. Remove the scene where Rumi and Jinu sing "Free" and the movie falls apart. Remove "What It Sounds Like" and you lose the climax. In Joker 2, the only number that is maybe critical is when Arthur and Harley first escape. Every other musical scene could be skipped, and that means you've failed as a musical. Phillips asked Warner Bros. to pay Lady Gaga $12 million to sing songs that aren't important to the story.

Arthur Fleck rejecting the Joker isn't set up by the first movie

Even ignoring the source material and the pointless musical scenes, the story doesn't work, because it's still a sequel to Joker. Arthur begins that film as a decent guy. He takes care of his mother, he isn't mean to people, and he wants to make people laugh. He only kills the men on the train because they were beating him, and the last time he was beaten up, no one believed him. As the movie goes on, his empathy disappears, which is why he's so happy on top of the car at the end.

The first film ends with Arthur gleefully running out of a meeting with his psychiatrist after potentially killing her. Because of Joker 2, we know he didn't, so the interpretation seems to be that he was fantasizing about it. Arthur isn't exactly like most versions of the Joker, but he no longer has empathy, he revels in violence and other people don't matter to him. That's fundamentally the Joker. I refuse to believe anyone who says he never embraced that personality. He was forced into it, which is why it's a tragedy, but he did embrace it.

So a sequel where he rejects being the Joker is reductive to the first movie, and the best writer in the world would still undermine it by going down this path. In theory, I think you could tell an excellent story about a man who almost became the Joker, realized it was wrong and died through his own creation. But across two films, you'd need to plant those seeds in the first one, with hints that Arthur doesn't love the violence he caused. That doesn't happen.

A passive Arthur and little chemistry with Harley Quinn

Let's assume the musical portions were well done and that Arthur abandoning his Joker persona is a natural progression. Is his arc executed well? No. People have joked that the movie takes place almost entirely in Arkham Asylum and the courthouse. Two locations aren't necessarily the problem. The problem is that keeping Arthur in captivity for almost the entire film severely limits the story.

In the first movie, Arthur was an active protagonist. Beyond the train killings, which were in defense of himself, he drives everything: killing his mom, killing another man, going on Murray Franklin's show, killing Murray Franklin, going after Thomas Wayne and embracing the violence at the end. In Joker 2, he mostly reacts. Harley seeks him out, much of the film is a back and forth between Harley and the lawyer over who he should trust, and even firing his lawyer is mostly Harley's influence. Then Gary Puddles gives his speech, Arthur is assaulted by the cops and he renounces the Joker identity. That's his first active choice not influenced by anyone else, and it comes at the end. I think it's fair to say most of the movie is boring.

His relationship with Harley could have been the element that engages viewers, but it isn't that interesting. Despite sharing significant screen time, they don't have great chemistry. I never bought that Arthur was in love with her. You could argue that's the point, that they only liked each other because of the Joker, but even if it's the point, it's still largely uninteresting.

How Harley Quinn could have made the story work

One option was surrounding Harley with more mystery. Early on she tells Arthur she was abused by her parents and thrown onto the streets. A few scenes later, the lawyer tells him she lied and is a rich girl who checked herself into Arkham, and when Arthur confronts her, she tells the truth. That was a wasted opportunity. What if no one told him, and he only found out at the end, partly causing him to reject the Joker? Combined with the Gary Puddles scene, which was the best scene in the movie, that still fits the tragedy Phillips was telling, and I think it would emphasize the tragic nature of the story more than what we got.

Another idea I've seen thrown around is telling the movie from Harley's perspective. It could open with her watching Arthur kill Murray Franklin on TV and celebrating in the streets, then follow her trying to get close to him and maybe break him out. Maybe she orchestrated the bomb that went off. Once she truly meets Arthur, she's disappointed. It could be a commentary on parasocial relationships, like Arthur's with Murray Franklin in the first movie but stronger. That would be a radically different movie, but one that might work better.

Why the trial robbed Joker: Folie à Deux of stakes

I think a major mistake, whichever direction they chose, was focusing so much on the trial. A courtroom drama needs back and forths, surprises and an audience actively invested in the outcome. This trial isn't exciting. It mostly shows the public's investment in Arthur, and it's largely about his mental state and whether he deserves the death penalty. Once he became the Joker at the end of the first film, I don't think we're worried about whether he dies. He's a villain now. I empathize with him, but I'm not invested in whether he lives.

In the first movie, after the train killings, the stakes were what he would do next. That's why the tension in the Murray Franklin scene is so strong, and then he does what we all fear. The trailers for Joker 2 teased Arthur escaping for a significant part of the film, and that could have been more interesting. Maybe he escapes early or halfway through, is put in the position of the clown prince of crime, and realizes while leading a movement that being the Joker isn't who he is.

In any version where he rejects the Joker, I'd keep the exchange with Gary, because that's what sells it. Arthur realizes he's become the bully, the way he was bullied in the first movie. That moment could happen outside court and lead him to turn himself in or get killed outside jail. Maybe I'm a little biased, since I tend to like my own ideas and don't like this movie, but on paper I like him being out of jail much more. Either way, the story needed more going on than a silly romance and an uninteresting trial.

Joker: Folie à Deux reception and box office

Joker: Folie à Deux scored 31% with critics on Rotten Tomatoes and a 31% audience score. On IMDb, it scored 5.2 out of 10. A year after release, there were no plans for another Joker movie of any kind, and no plans for Todd Phillips to return to DC.

The film was made on a budget of $200 million and earned less than 20% of what the first movie made. It was without question a box office failure.

What other creators are saying

More on Joker →
The Deep Dive · more than 410,000 subscribers
I believe the Joker's makeup, applied and altered scene by scene, hints at a hidden true story Nolan deliberately never confirms, and I think small details like melted paint, fresh lipstick, and possible green screen trickery suggest his origin is even more unknowable and multiple choice than fans realize.

The Dark Knight: What the Joker's Makeup Reveals Scene by Scene →

Breakdowns & Blockbusters · more than 240,000 subscribers
No, the Joker role itself did not break him. His death resulted from a perfect storm of exhaustion, an unforgiving work schedule, personal emotional stress, chronic insomnia and a growing reliance on prescription medications, culminating in an accidental overdose.

Did the Joker break Heath Ledger? What really happened →

Sorta Stupid · more than 810,000 subscribers · Snippet
A turn in the 2010 animated Batman film left me stunned and reminded me of the Joker

Batman: Under the Red Hood twist left me in disbelief, and I think the Joker would want it →

Watch the original

@thegoldman25 · YouTube

Adapted with AI from The Gold Man's video of 5 October 2025 and checked against the video before publication. Editorial standards · Corrections

Joker: Folie à DeuxJokerTodd PhillipsJoaquin PhoenixLady GagaHarley QuinnDCArthur Fleck

More from @thegoldman25

All →
Write for SUBPLOT

Make videos? Your next one could be an article here.

We turn your videos into articles under your name, linked back to the original. You keep 60% of what they earn, non-exclusive, and you can leave whenever you like.

Become a SubPlotter →